Proposal: Transfer Ownership of the Polkadot Brand to the Polkadot DAO

I believe it is time for the Polkadot brand to become an asset of the Polkadot DAO, rather than remain under the ownership of Web3 Foundation.

I would like to propose that Web3 Foundation transfer ownership of the Polkadot brand and its associated trademarks to the Polkadot DAO, with the Polkadot Community Foundation (PCF) acting as the legal entity through which the transfer is carried out and the trademarks are held.

This would be a meaningful step towards greater decentralization, ensuring that the Polkadot community has ownership and control over the identity and brand of the ecosystem it governs.

I would therefore like to ask Web3 Foundation to consider initiating this transfer in coordination with the PCF and the Polkadot community.

Correct me if I am wrong, but isn’t this what Polkadot DAO achieved?

Polkadot Inter Miami ($10.5M), StellaSwap incentives ($6.4M), Mythical Games swap ($6.6M), Giotto marketing proposals ($10.9M), etc.

Millions of $$ to the drain.

Is this for what you want to transfer the ownership of Polkadot brand?

With this amount of grift happening on the treasury it would taint Polkadot brand forever. It is better the Polkadot brand stays with the PCF.

Hi @ultracoconut, interesting idea. I’d like to look at it from a structural angle, since the brand is only as “community-owned” as the entity that holds it.

1. Ownership is not control

“An asset of the DAO” can’t mean literal ownership, because a legal entity has to hold the trademarks. In your post that’s the PCF. So the DAO would hold nothing directly. It would influence an entity, and the quality of that influence is what matters. The question is less “who owns the brand” and more “who can instruct, remove or override the holder”.

2. What we know about how the PCF is steered

  • It was set up as a Cayman Islands foundation company whose activities are directed by DOT holders via OpenGov (post 2278). polkassembly
  • Full drafts of its governance documents were shared with the original proposal (ref 730). Are the final versions public, and do they still say the same thing? subsquare
  • A comment on ref 1082 mentions “DOT Directors” and an intended “3vs2” composition, which suggests the articles define board seats. I can’t tell from the thread what that composition is, or whether it changed. polkassembly
  • Its renewal proposal describes the PCF as a bridge between on-chain governance and real-world execution (ref 1591). polkassembly

That tells me intent. It doesn’t tell me what happens in a conflict. If OpenGov and the board disagree about the trademarks, which prevails, and how would it be enforced in court?

3. A trademark needs active stewardship

As far as I know, in most jurisdictions a trademark holder has to control how the mark is used, or the mark can weaken. So whoever holds it needs published brand-use rules, a licensing policy and a way to enforce it. Who writes those, who can change them, and what is the appeal path?

4. Concentration risk

Moving the brand to one entity turns it into a single point of failure and pressure: litigation, a hostile jurisdiction, a board capture. W3F already has this problem. The question is whether we’d improve it or only change the name on the door. There are alternatives worth discussing: a public licence for the mark, a split between the mark and the domains, or a holding structure with on-chain appointment of the board.

5. Questions

  1. Where are the PCF’s current governing documents published, and who sits on its board?
  2. In a conflict between OpenGov and the board, who wins, and how is it enforced?
  3. Who holds the brand today, and under what licences do W3F, Parity and others use it?
  4. What brand-use policy would the holder publish, and who could change it?
  5. If the PCF is the right holder, what would make it capture-resistant?

I’m not against the idea. I’d just like to see these answers before anyone calls the brand “owned by the DAO”.