Hi. You can’t have one person, one vote without a trusted authority, or other trust assumptions that replace it, to check who is a unique person (Douceur’s result, “The Sybil Attack”, 2002). Today that authority is your committee.
What you are asking is: can we avoid a Sybil attack without asking for IDs in a Proof of Authority chain?
That is in essence a proof of personhood problem. There are some ways to approach it (e.g. Encointer with simultaneous in-person meetups, BrightID with social vouching, Idena with synchronized puzzles). They don’t need IDs, but they replace the central authority with other trust assumptions, such as physical presence, simultaneous human tests, or a trusted social graph, and each one has its own weaknesses.
But there is another issue that your question is not addressing: economic security. Let’s say you are able to identify unique identities (with or without asking for IDs). Then you have a set of unique identities that have voting power.
What ensures that those people/entities will not misbehave?
In a PoW chain, miners invest in hardware that is only valuable if the chain keeps its value, so mining honestly pays more than attacking.
In a PoS chain, if you misbehave you get slashed and lose your stake.
In a PoA chain, validators are usually known institutions. If one misbehaves, the other validators remove it, but the real deterrent is the loss of its reputation. Lawsuits are possible, because the identity is known.
In MADAR, without IDs or stake, you end up with a group of entities with nothing to lose except their seat and future rewards. To attack the network, someone only has to pay enough operators to get a majority of the votes, and with a small operator set that is cheap. The cost of that attack does not grow with the value the chain secures, but the gain does.
One possible direction: move to a regular PoA with known identities. That means giving up the “no IDs” goal, but it gives you the deterrent that PoA depends on: reputation and legal action, while keeping one person, one vote.