How XCM will actually be used with XCMP

I agree with this. I wrote it before in [Discussion/Idea] Domain/Pallet specific XCM language · Issue #30 · paritytech/xcm-format · GitHub (for different reasons), that we are not in a spot right now where we can define XCM properly.

I believe there will be more to XCM but we also have to be realistic. Until there is a technological breakthrough, the majority of activity will be around Token/NFT transfers. New scenarios are coming but those are very limited (by the nature of blockchains)

Interacting from a blockchain with the real world (which is what people want to at the end, specially if we want to do something else than Defi) requires to either trust the interaction (like our current society works) or use a physically/mathematically proven interaction (which we don’t have invented yet).
Leaning into the “trust” scenario can work (Ex: people trust tokens have real $ value) and might help to bring some new scenarios, but it is also not the direction of the promises of the blockchain technology.

Working on XCM and cross-chain in general is about preparing the base/platform for that evolution, but we don’t know what it will look like, so I believe XCM can’t be designed for it now.

However, we should still consider XCM, to help the ecosystem pave the road and learn from the challenges associated with cross-chain, in order maybe to evolve to another version or another language that will match the real scenarios we will have.

My 2 cents,
Alan

1 Like